Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak – Which Gives You the Most for Your Money



All of a sudden everybody needs a fitness monitor. Just a few years ago, the only people who used these devices to track their daily steps or to compare daily activity levels were elite athletes. Today, it seems as if more people are wearing them than aren’t.

So what has changed? First, there’s been a lot more awareness about the link between daily activity level and such things as obesity, the risk of heart disease and even cancer. There’s even a recent report that says sitting is the new smoking. Can you imagine!

Second, the technology in wearable fitness monitors has ramped up considerably in recent years. The best-selling models a few years back offered relatively little information compared to today’s high tech monitors. Now you can see at a glance such things as your daily steps, your heart rate, and where you have been. Plus today’s devices integrate with software that can provide you with an entire array of analytics instantly.

While there are actually dozens of different wearable fitness monitors on the market today, today we are going to look at two of the most popular and provide a side by side comparison of Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak.

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak – Which Has Better Design?

Functionality be damned! What most people want in a wearable fitness monitor is that it look super cool and sleek. Right?

When comparing Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak, both score high on style points. The Fitness Surge comes in a bigger selection of colors, unlike Basis Peak, which only comes in basic black or white. Having said that, many of the colored models of Fitbit Surge are so popular that retailers and the Fitbit website often only have the black available. So much for that advantage!

Fitbit Surge offers three different size options as well. It has a monochrome screen that lets you cycle through all of your current stats by using a little button on its left hand side. It comes with a stretchable, elastomer band that is built for comfort.

In contrast, the Basis Peak looks like a basic black box on your wrist. It has a 1.25-inch monochrome square which, like the Fitbit Surge, uses a physical button to scroll through your states. It also has a backlight you can illuminate by swiping up the right hand bezel.

When it comes to Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak and waterproofing, Basic Peak comes out on top, offering complete moisture protection up to 50 meters. Fitbit Surge probably can be safely worn in the shower if you forget to take it off, but that’s about it.

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak Design Winner – Fitbit Surge

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak – Which Has Better Sensors?

When it comes to sensors, Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak both have their benefits. Both feature hear rate monitors that measure your pulse from your wrist, rather than through the kind of heart rate monitor you wear around your chest. (Oh, to go back to 2002!) Both also will track your steps and measure your calories burned.

But the Basis Peak also measures your galvanic skin response – in other words, how much you are sweating – as well as your skin temperature. This data can then be integrated with various software programs that can give you real time data on athletic performance. Pretty high tech stuff.

The Fitbit Surge scores better on the way its axis accelerometer, gyroscope, compass and altimeter data can be incorporated with your heart rate data to give you a better overall picture of your workouts.

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak Sensors Winner – Fitbit Surge

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak – Which Offers the Best Sports Tracking?

For the first time ever, Fitbit’s Surge lets you track different types of activities, rather than simply the number of steps you take every day or your sleep patterns. It tracks your running, biking, lifting, cross-training and cardio workouts, as well as your calories.
For example, you can use the Fitbit Surge to keep track of your split times, pace, distances, and even which routes you follow. And it integrates all this information into your heart rate data so you can pinpoint when you were really hitting it hard and when you were dogging it (as if you didn’t already know!)

The Basis Peak also automatically tracks different types of activities, but it really doesn’t give you as much hard data as the Fitbit Surge when it comes to detailed information for running vs lifting, for example.

So in terms of sports tracking, the battle of Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak goes to the Fitbit device.

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak Sports Tracking Winner – Fitbit Surge

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak – Which Offers the Best Sports Tracking?

Fitbit Surge’s apps are pretty cool. They let you see your workout history, workout details, general activity data, maps of your running routes, and graphs of your pace, distance and elevation. Plus, it’s still the only major wearable fitness monitor that works with the Windows Phone (as well as iPhones and Android devices, of course).

The Basis Peak also gives you a lot of information, such as your step count and daily activity stats. There’s a cool website that encourages you to work toward your fitness goals. But the data it provides regarding individual runs or workout performances are substantially less than the Fitbit Surge.

Things are starting to tip toward one side in the Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak battle!

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak Apps Winner – Fitbit Surge

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak – Which Offers the Best Sports Tracking?

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak – Price Considerations

Finally, here is an area where the Basis Peak comes out on top. You can get the basic model for about $199, compared to the $249 it will cost you for the Fitbit Surge.

Yet, for that extra $50, the Fitbit Surge gives you a lot more cool apps, a sleeker look, and a ton of additional data you can use to both monitor and modify your workouts for optimal physical benefits.

So when it comes to Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak and cost, the Basis Peak may be cheaper but it also offers you little more than the bare basics.

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak Price Winner – Fitbit Surge

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak – The Bottom Line

In terms of overall features and data, it’s a no brainer: If you can afford it, get the Fitbit Surge.
But if you are looking for a bare bones wearable fitness monitor that you want to be able to wear in the pool, then the Basis Peak is probably a better choice.

Fitbit Surge vs Basis Peak Overall Winner – Draw, depending on your budget and needs

To learn more visit: